When Tree Removal Is Actually Needed

Not every problematic tree needs to be removed. Removal should be considered when:

Dead or Dying Trees

A tree with more than 50% dead branches, no leaf growth in season, extensive bark loss, or significant decay is likely beyond saving. Dead trees become brittle and unpredictable, posing serious safety risks.

Structural Instability

Trees with severe lean (especially recent changes), major trunk cracks, significant root damage, or hollow trunks may fail without warning. If a tree leans more than 15 degrees toward structures, it requires professional assessment.

Disease or Infestation Beyond Treatment

Some tree diseases and pest infestations cannot be treated effectively. Removing infected trees prevents spread to healthy trees and protects your landscape investment.

Construction or Renovation Requirements

Sometimes removal is unavoidable for property development, though alternatives like transplanting should be explored first when possible.

Wrong Tree, Wrong Location

Trees planted too close to foundations, sewer lines, or structures may cause ongoing damage that exceeds the cost of removal and replacement with a more suitable species.

When Removal Is NOT Needed

Many homeowners consider removal when other solutions would work better:

  • Messy trees: Seasonal leaf drop, fruit, or sap is natural. Choose native species for new plantings if maintenance is a concern.
  • Too much shade: Selective pruning (crown thinning) can increase light penetration by 15-30% without removing the tree.
  • Minor branch concerns: Dead or damaged branches can often be pruned rather than removing the entire tree.
  • View blocking: Crown raising or selective branch removal may restore views while keeping the tree.
  • Minor lean: Trees naturally lean toward light. A slight lean (under 10 degrees) is usually not dangerous.
  • Wildlife concerns: Birds, squirrels, and insects in trees are normal. Removal is rarely the best solution unless there's a health hazard (like bees near an allergic person).

Get a Second Opinion

If an arborist recommends removal, especially for a large or mature tree, consider getting a second assessment. Some contractors prefer removal (more profitable) when pruning or treatment would be appropriate.

Permit Requirements in North Vancouver

The District of North Vancouver has strict tree protection bylaws. Here's what you need to know:

When You Need a Permit

  • Any tree over 20cm (8 inches) diameter measured at 1.4 meters (4.5 feet) from the ground
  • Trees on your property that are designated as "protected"
  • Trees near property lines that may affect neighbors
  • Multiple tree removals in a short time period

Protected Trees

North Vancouver protects certain species and sizes. Protected trees typically cannot be removed without exceptional circumstances. These include:

  • Trees over 60cm (24 inches) diameter
  • Old growth specimens
  • Trees in environmentally sensitive areas
  • Heritage trees designated by the municipality

Exemptions (No Permit Required)

  • Trees under 20cm diameter
  • Trees that pose imminent danger (must be documented)
  • Dead trees (arborist certification required)
  • Specific invasive species (confirmation needed)

Application Process

Applying for a tree removal permit typically involves:

  1. Submit application to District of North Vancouver (online or in-person)
  2. Provide arborist report justifying removal
  3. Pay application fee ($150-$300 typically)
  4. Wait 4-6 weeks for review and decision
  5. If approved, pay permit fee and any required replacement tree security deposit

⚠️ Penalties for Unpermitted Removal

Removing a tree without required permits can result in:

  • Fines up to $10,000 per tree
  • Mandatory replacement tree planting at your expense
  • Security deposit (held for 2-3 years to ensure replacement survives)
  • Potential legal action from neighbors if their property is affected

Typical Costs in North Vancouver

Tree removal costs vary significantly based on size, location, and access. Here are typical ranges for North Vancouver:

Small Trees

Under 20 feet (6 meters)

$300 - $1,200

  • Usually removed in sections
  • Can often be done in one day
  • Lower equipment needs

Medium Trees

20-40 feet (6-12 meters)

$1,200 - $3,500

  • Requires climbing equipment
  • 1-2 day project
  • Crane may be needed

Large Trees

40-60 feet (12-18 meters)

$3,500 - $7,000

  • Multi-day project
  • Crane often required
  • Higher risk and expertise

Very Large Trees

Over 60 feet (18+ meters)

$7,000 - $15,000+

  • Complex rigging needed
  • Specialized equipment
  • Multiple crew days

Additional Cost Factors

  • Stump Grinding: Add $150-$500 depending on size
  • Difficult Access: Add 25-50% for narrow gates, steep slopes
  • Emergency Service: Expect 50-100% premium for immediate response
  • Near Power Lines: May require BC Hydro coordination, adding time and cost
  • Crane Rental: $500-$2,000 per day if needed
  • Permit Fees: $150-$300 for application, plus potential security deposits
  • Debris Removal: Usually included, but confirm in quote

Safety Considerations

Tree removal is one of the most dangerous jobs in forestry. Here's why you should never attempt DIY removal of anything larger than a small shrub:

Unpredictable Fall Patterns

Trees rarely fall where you expect. Internal rot, wind, weight distribution, and root structure all affect fall direction. Professional arborists use rigging systems to control every piece.

Electrical Hazards

Trees within 3 meters of power lines require specialized protocols. Contact with lines can be fatal. Only certified professionals should work near electrical infrastructure.

Equipment Risks

Chainsaws cause thousands of serious injuries annually. Professional arborists undergo extensive training in saw operation, climbing safety, and emergency response.

Property Damage

A falling tree can destroy your home, vehicle, or neighbor's property. Professional arborists carry $2-5 million in liability insurance. Your homeowner's policy likely won't cover damage from DIY tree work.

What to Expect During Professional Removal

Understanding the process helps you prepare and know what questions to ask:

  1. Site Assessment: Arborist evaluates tree condition, fall zone, access, and hazards
  2. Planning: Determines removal method (crane, climbing, rigging) and equipment needed
  3. Site Preparation: Clears area, sets up safety zones, protects property
  4. Dismantling: Removes tree in sections from top down, using ropes and rigging to control each piece
  5. Stump Treatment: Grinds stump below ground level (if requested)
  6. Cleanup: Removes all debris, chips wood if desired, rakes area
  7. Final Inspection: Walkthrough to ensure site is clean and safe

Need Help With Tree Removal?

Get guidance on your specific situation and connect with qualified, insured arborists in North Vancouver.

Get Free Assessment